09 April 2020
Coronavirus (COVID-19): considerations for commercial landlords and tenants in Guernsey
The COVID-19 pandemic has created a number of implications for commercial landlords and tenants in Guernsey. The commercial property industry on Guernsey has in particular taken note of the three-month moratorium on commercial lease forfeiture in England and Wales under the Coronavirus Act 2020.
Whatever emergency measures may be introduced, the following briefing provides a brief summary of some key areas of law that will need to be considered in relation to commercial leases and associated agreements over the coming months.
Many commercial contracts have “force majeure clauses”. These clauses provide parameters for when a party may terminate the contract and/or be excused for failure or delay in complying with the terms of the contract due to a specified event. The contract will usually specify which events constitute a force majeure event, and so depending on the drafting, a pandemic may not necessarily be covered within the force majeure provisions.
Whilst most commercial leases in Guernsey may not contain an express force majeure clause (and so the parties will not be able to rely on such an option in the event COVID-19 leads (directly or indirectly) to breaches of the lease), force majeure clauses are regularly included within agreements to lease where parties are committed to take a lease once a building has been constructed or other works completed. Landlords and developers with ongoing development projects should review such force majeure provisions carefully, especially if the COVID-19 pandemic is likely to have an adverse effect on the completion of their development.
Most commercial leases will contain provisions allowing for rent to be suspended where the premises have been damaged or destroyed by an insured risk, and it has become increasingly common for this to be extended also to include any damage by uninsured risks.
It is questionable whether such clauses would be triggered by an inability to use a building due to the COVID-19 pandemic as it is highly unlikely that physical damage or destruction will arise due to COVID-19. However, some rent suspension clauses may be drafted more broadly, to allow for rent to be suspended in circumstances other than where the premises are damaged or destroyed by an insured risk.
Both landlords and tenants will need to carefully review and consider the rent abatement clauses within their commercial leases. In the current climate, it is also important for landlords to review their buildings insurance policy and rent loss policies to determine if disease or epidemics would be covered as an insured risk. Equally, tenants should be reviewing their business interruption policies in the event that they are precluded from occupying the premises from which their business operates.
Commercial leases will usually contain express provisions setting out circumstances in which a landlord may take steps to formally cancel the lease and seek an order for vacant possession. Usually this will include where the rent remains unpaid for anywhere between 7 – 30 days after falling due.
In relation to cancellation or forfeiture of leases, as a matter of Guernsey law a tenant may only be dispossessed (evicted) from his occupation of premises by an order of the Royal Court of Guernsey, notwithstanding that the terms of the lease may provide for it to be terminated on the occurrence of specified events. In practice, the Royal Court will only order the eviction of a tenant if it is satisfied that there has been a breach of the terms of the lease such as to render an order for eviction just and appropriate in the circumstances. The likelihood of successfully obtaining such an eviction order for unpaid rent for reasons associated with the recent pandemic will be highly dependent on the factual circumstances, but the security of tenure of a tenant will undoubtedly be stronger now than in usual circumstances.
The best advice for any tenants who are struggling to pay their rent is to speak to their landlord as soon as possible to discuss if any alternative payment or other arrangements can be agreed (see our ‘practical steps’ section below).
Turnover rents will very likely be significantly impacted, either due to a reduction in turnover or, in cases where the tenant has had to cease operating, no turnover at all. As always, the impact will depend on the drafting of the turnover provisions within the lease.
For example, there may be a clause that, where the premises are closed for trading by the tenant on a trading day during the turnover period, the turnover for that day will be deemed to be equivalent to the average daily turnover for those days that the premises was actually open for trading during the turnover period. Often, however, this deemed turnover will not apply where the premises have been closed for reasons beyond the tenant’s reasonable control (as would be the case if forced to close due to COVID-19), or for a force majeure event.
Without this deemed turnover, the inevitable result of reduced hours or closure will be lower turnover and consequently lower turnover rent, but many turnover provisions will likely have a base minimum payable, regardless of actual turnover.
It is important to remember that, regardless of when the actual rent review is taking place, the key is the date of the rent review. If parties are still negotiating the revised rent for a review date that has already passed, they must determine what the hypothetical rent would have been on that date – not as of the current date.
For imminently approaching rent review dates, it is likely that matters relating to COVID-19 and which affect the property in question will be taken into account when determining the hypothetical rent as at the review date.
Certain commercial leases for retail premises may have keep-open clauses, whereby the tenant must keep the premises open for certain times of certain days. Should the tenant close the premises of its own volition, it will likely be in breach of such obligations. Even if closing due to government requirements, on the face of it the tenant would still be in breach of this clause, and most leases provide a right for the landlord to cancel the lease in the event of breach by the tenant of its obligations.
However, all leases will usually contain a requirement to comply with law. Where compliance with law would put the tenant in breach of another covenant in the lease such as a keep-open clause, compliance with law would of course generally be expected to take precedence.
Building access and security
Where the landlord has closed the building due to a government order, it will be difficult for a tenant to argue that the landlord is in breach of its obligations for granting quiet and peaceful enjoyment of the premises. In such circumstances, the tenant will be required to continue paying rent unless this is covered by the rent suspension provisions in the lease (see above), or otherwise agreed with the landlord.
If, however, there is no governmental guidance or requirement but the landlord has still shut the building, preventing the tenant from accessing it, then there may be an argument that the landlord has breached its obligation to allow quiet and peaceful enjoyment. By contrast, it should be permissible for a landlord to introduce rules governing access to common parts where reasonable, as most leases for multi-let buildings will provide for this.
Where a building is forced to close, it is essential that it is safely secured. Even where this responsibility falls to the tenant under the lease, the landlord should ensure that it has been properly done so that any insurance policy is not invalidated. It is also important to notify the insurer if the premises will be left unattended for any period of time.
Services and cleaning
In a multi-let building or a building where the landlord provides the usual services, it is likely that the responsible landlord will arrange for heightened cleaning services in order to minimise chances of contagion. Common steps are to schedule more frequent cleaning of door handles, light switches, lift buttons and other high-usage fixtures and fittings, as well as providing hand sanitizer and cleansing wipes.
Additionally, it is common for inclusion of a “sweeper clause”, often expressed to cover any additional services carried out by the landlord in the interests of good estate management, and it would be hard to argue that additional cleaning during a pandemic would not fall within this definition.
Many commercial leases contain break clauses, which can be exercised by the landlord, the tenant or both (if a mutual break clause). It is likely that over the next 12 months some tenants may look to exercise any break option available in an effort to mitigate the effect of the COVID-19 pandemic. Tenants or landlords intending to exercise a break option must read the lease provisions carefully, as many attempted breaks have been frustrated by incorrect service of the break notice, or by the tenant not giving vacant possession.
Whilst we await with interest what emergency measures the States of Guernsey may propose in respect of commercial leases, landlords and tenants must start having an open dialogue and work together to find sensible and practical solutions to ensure that a tenant’s business can survive in the long term whilst at the same time protecting the landlord’s income-stream.
It is essential that such commercial negotiations start as soon as possible. Some concessions which might be considered include:
- permitting the tenant to pay rent on a monthly rather than a quarterly basis in order to better regulate cash flow;
- deferring the rent (in whole or in part) for a temporary period, perhaps coupled with an extension of the term to assist with the payment of deferred rent amounts; and/or
- repaying tenants any overpaid service charge at the end of the service charge year following reconciliation, rather than deducting this from future instalments.
Once terms are agreed, it is important that any side letter or forbearance agreement is precisely drafted to ensure that the lease itself is not inadvertently varied or obligations waived, and to ensure all relevant aspects are carefully considered. Landlords must also consider their own obligations to lenders, insurers and any superior landlords.
The property law group at Carey Olsen can assist with the negotiation and drafting of rent concessions and the preparation of necessary and unambiguous documentation to properly record and implement any concessions or forbearance that may be agreed.
CORONAVIRUS (COVID-19) RESOURCES
We have produced a number of client briefings to assist you in assessing and mitigating the extensive challenges presented by the coronavirus situation. This content is housed in dedicated coronavirus (COVID-19) resources hub.